Tuesday, July 24, 2012

"Dark Knight" Shootings: When Do We LEARN?


Another massacre has been committed by yet another deranged gunman---whether he be sociopathic, schizophrenic, or bipolar is not the point for the moment—and yet the USA is doing the same old things it does every time there’s a similar massacre, which is more than one a year now. That’s right, here in the USA there are several massacres a year, if you count the “incidental” ones that don’t get too much media attention, like a postal worker shooting himself and three others in rural Alabama, or four people in a WAWA store in Maine killed during a robbery. Not to mention the infamous one of last year in which Jared Loughner, who has been deemed mentally unfit to stand trial due to paranoid schizophrenia, shot at U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Gifford and killed several people in the process.

But this is all we do, every time:

1. Hold prayer vigils and offer “soothing words” to use Mayor Bloomberg’s succinct phrase

2. Congratulate everyone involved on their braveness and law enforcement on their rapid response; which is all very honorable but what does it change?

3. Wish the gunman was dead and fantasize about how we’d like to kill him, as if doing that will change anything.



What we should be doing in order to prevent more irrevocable violence and having to endlessly repeat steps 1 to 3:

4. Pass gun control laws so that Nobody can BUY an Assault Rifle of any kind, and nobody can buy more than 1 Handgun in an Entire YEAR.

5. Have longer wait periods for buying guns.

6. Have a mandatory psych test before you can buy a gun.

7. Make the state laws for psychiatric committal just a little less stringent, so that when mentally disturbed people start to show themselves as being deranged, we can force them to get help while they still can be helped.

        It is important to recognize that sociopaths, like Ted Bundy, are classified separately from schizophrenics, like Jared Loughner, who told other college classmates that his math teacher was missing the messages the numbers were trying to send! In many ways, sociopaths, who have no brain disease but cannot feel empathy, are more dangerous than most schizophrenics will ever be. Many people with bipolar or schizophrenia can be helped to live productive lives IF they get medicine and therapy before they develop violent tendencies. James Holmes, as everyone has seen, started out a normal high school student who was involved in extra-curricular activities such as playing soccer with the other guys, in addition to being on the honor roll. As we all see, it took him several years to "break"--- during which he earned a BA from a top college and began a  MA in another-- years in which he could have been helped and the massacre prevented.

Yes, we love our guns and our “freedom” here in the U.S., but we should look around the world for once instead of being so megalomaniac, and see that no other country has so many massacres by deranged gunman, yet alone no other country has such a high rate of accidental gun deaths and murders through shootings. How many times do these things happen in England? In France? In Germany? In Japan?

They say that repeating the same method while still expecting to get a different result is the hallmark of insanity, and by that criterion-- the way we refuse to control gun ownership and  work more on mental health prevention--then my fellow Americans are insane.




10 comments:

  1. Hello Catharine, yes it is all too tragic for words. Thanks for highlighting this issue in such an articulate way. Freud wrote about the repetition compulsion (compulsion to repeat) i.e. that the individual -and this can be stretched to society in that the microcosm is part of the macrocosm - will continue to enact the same unhealthy or destructive act even if it does not cause 'pleasure'. We do not learn from history .. if we did and released ourselves from infantility, the world would surely be a better place.
    I worry about gun control .. it is such an emotive subject. Politicians will use this argument to win votes from those in favour of it, but as we know big business is most times involved in the very thing that is opposed by the public. Vested interests. Prohibition brings it own problems - take it underground and then it festers in whatever way, an unhealthy way.
    Is there a solution to preventing deranged gunmen from going on a killing spree? What leads a person to become deranged? Where does it all start? In the family? Children who have absent fathers and mothers, or abusive parents, alcoholic parents which may lead the child later as an adult to feel they themselves have no control over their lives? Lack of empathic schooling? Lack of mental health facilities? Lack of awareness within the community where each looks out for the other?
    Writing as I am from South Africa, I can only empathize ... here, rape of women and children is rife.
    Education in my view is the only way to beat this scourge of needless violence. The values that we upheld and continue to, seem to have gotten lost somehow. Love thy neighbour as thyself etc .. look out for your fellow man. Please G.d may we have more awareness about the children we bring forth into the world and offer them safe passage. As women, we have a particular role to play here in carefully choosing our partner with whom we elect to bring children into the world.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for that lovely, enlightened and comprehensive response, Susan! Yes, all of the above missing factors in society contribute to this situation: lack of proper parents, dysfunctional family dynamics, lack of proper and affordable mental health facilities in communities, and the overabundance of guns in the U.S.

    I do feel more gun control is needed, but as you said, it would bring a risk of more guns going black market, underground. It is too late for us a society to become like England, where the people have been used to being without guns for centuries and do not resent it. However, there should be mandatory psych evaluations before buying a gun, and limits to how many you can buy and what type.

    I also feel that there are many mentally unhealthy individuals within the mental health professional community, which is where James Eagen Holmes was headed in his career, and that there should be mandatory psychological exams for anyone seeking licensing in any mental health professional capacity. There have been documented cases of doctors and psychologists abusing their families or others, and no one minds the store or regulates the so called professionals who are in charge of society's mental health.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I wanted to add, Susan, that you are totally right that women do have a special role to play in choosing the right partner who will make an excellent father, but sadly so many women also repeat mistakes of the past, often ones that mirror dysfunction in their family of origin.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Catharine,
    i believe things like this happens more often in Germany than is told in the USA on their news channels.
    We have a lot of women abuse here in Germany. There are killings of women everyday, especially if they seek a divorce from their spouses.
    Gun control needs to be exercised all over the world. They have here in Germany shooting clubs and the guns are supposed to be locked up in a safe place at all times, but that is not always the case.
    Thank you for an informative article that makes me think about gun control here.
    Ciao,
    Patricia

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Pat,

    Yes, I agree, news of murder in Germany--whether by gun or other
    weapon-- is very unreported here in the US and probably also in
    Canada. I didn't know about the abundance of wife abuse, but I have read in reputable child advocacy sources that there is a disturbing problem with child molestation and child prostitution there that is equal to ours and perhaps greater. I've read that many German males are making use of the child prostitution trafficking ring next door in Poland or other Eastern European countries.

    I never thought Germany was perfect, but from what I was hearing in the US, there were fewer mass shootings-i.e., gunmen going out and shooting strangers en mass. Yet, of course shooting or beating your wife is just as wrong, evil, and unacceptable. Yes, gun control and anger control and lessons in respecting others need to be taught everywhere. Thanks again for your comments!
    Blessings,
    Catharine

    ReplyDelete
  6. The thing is Catherine is that the 'freedom' those die-hard 2nd amendment lunatics think they're defending? Doesn't even exist! Those guns (along with assorted sociopaths, schizophrenics, etc..),have actually had the opposite effect and effectively jailed people in their own homes! The burglar alarms, the guard dogs, the barred windows - we're terrified of each other! Your ideas for amendment are excellent and still allow the gun-heads their toys - IN MODERATION! i don't get how anyone doesn't get this! The old argument of 'guns don't kill - people do' is just plain bullshit - NO GUN - NO SHOOT - end of killing..Then there's the one's who say 'welllllll...the bad guys will get guns anyway'...well maybe - but not so goddamned easily or readily and with far more chance of exposure!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Linda. I agree that the freedom people talk about from having guns is an illusion. Some people, like Ted Nugent, say that the answer to the Dark Knight massacre is for the audience to have been armed. What a joke! The massacre would have been worse in terms of dead, with people shooting at one another through the fog of the tear gas, killing other innocent people. The average joe is not a marksman and never will be, lacking the necessary talent.

      No, people need to realize that more guns equals more insanity, and we need more gun control. So many people who think owning a gun will save them don't even have time to reach it in a home invasion, etc, meanwhile children die every day from finding their parents' guns in the house. Guns are not the answer.

      Delete
  7. Hi Catherine, I saw you on Linked in so I came to have a look and I am glad I did. I particularly like your last paragraph. I am not sure that the idea of mental health prevention is just a difference in expression between British and American English or whether you meant it in a tongue in cheek way but I thought either way the idea that efforts were being put into preventing mental health was very poignant.

    I don't think we have actually been without guns for centuries here in England as I can recall one of the arguments in favour of allowing people to carry pistols dealt with a story from approximately a century ago where a policeman was able to borrow one from a passerby whilst pursuing a criminal. Absolute ownership of pistols was only outlawed a few decades ago in response to a shooting in a school somewhere up north I believe.

    At first I thought your views were too extreme to be credible in America but I quickly realised that you were actually being quite measured. I am sure that you would like to express far more extreme views than you actually did. If nothing else there should certainly be a far higher threshold to reach before being allowed to purchase a weapon. I sometimes consider buying a rifle myself but I do not try because I operate under the assumption that I would be unlikely to be given a licence for one reason or another. If a few more people thought like that then ownership would likely drop a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Well, Harry, please don't be so sure that I would like to express much more extreme views than I did, because that is not the case concerning guns. I am not totally against the ownership of guns in the US, especially considering how deeply rooted our use of guns has been since the frontier days, when they were used to shoot game for food, kill attacking animals, etc.
    Forgive me if I got the number of centuries wrong with the gun laws in England, but I know it has been quite some time since private gun ownership was the legal norm there. I do know it's been centuries since England has a had a wild frontier full of unexplored forests to conquer such we had in America as late as the 1800's.

    I'm not sure what you meant by my views possible being too extreme to be "credible in America?" Did you mean that it's not credible that I could have those views as an American, or did you mean my views were not "suited" for America? Either way I'm glad you changed your mind.

    It's interesting that you say you saw me on Linkedin, because I cannot find you there, not by spelling your name exactly as you have it posted here.You must go under a different name on Linkedin.

    The phrase "mental health prevention" was meant to refer to preventative services in mental health, and it wasn't meant in a tongue-in-cheek fashion.

    By the way, my name is properly spelled "Catharine" not "Catherine" as you wrote it. My spelling is an older spelling that was fairly common in the 18th and 19th centuries; for example there was Harriet Beecher Stowe's sister Catharine Beecher, a well known writer of the time, and Catharine Macauley, a prominent author of the late 18th century.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi,
    I have nominated your blog for the blog of the year 2012. If you want to participate, please go to http://garciaandwalkon.me and follow the instructions on the blog of the year 2012 award.
    Have a great second Advent's Sunday.
    Ciao,
    Patricia

    ReplyDelete